Twitter – I’m torn.

The title says it all really, I have two contrasting views on Twitter.

First up it’s fun and possibly useful, of that there is no doubt. Chris Brogan summed it up recently on the blog.

  • You can research things rapidly.
  • “Everything” is happening on Twitter first – so can you afford to be not in on things?
  • Friendsourcing
  • Micro-Attention-Sharing
  • Direct People to Good Causes (This I like very much)
  • Yep – you can keep in touch with people – “what are you doing?”

The downside is the sheer “noise” both literal and metaphorical. When I am working I usually have music playing quietly on iTunes or Spotify and the distraction of new messages arriving is a test of my tolerance – so I turn Tweetdeck (other applications are available) off and frequently forget to turn it back on again – so it’s obvious I don’t miss it. But, & it’s a big but, when I do have it turned on I’m drawn in.

I do tend to retweet others’ postings a lot, possibly because there’s a feeling of “I do wish I had said that”, and it’s my way of proving George Bernard Shaw correct when he responded to Oscar Wilde “You will, Oscar, you will.” Actually my reason for re-tweeting is the reason that I will carry mentions of most things events, courses, services on my blog and newsletter (even for other coaches with rarely a quid pro quo – if you’re reading, you know who you are); it’s to share information etc that I consider to be useful.

But it’s the sheer volume of posts that I can’t handle, I want to keep reading, “is there something that I might have missed?” It might be better if there were only the 140 symbols available, so that website addresses couldn’t be included. When a tweet carries a link to a website or a blog posting I can end up “losing” an hour or more as I follow down the leafy lanes of cyperspace losing myself in copses and thickets and jumping fences into new fields.

The other element I don’t grasp is why do so many people want to follow me? What does an executive in North Dakota find so blooming fascinating about what I might have to say? Does he really think he’s going to be able to sell me something? Apparently most people (unlike Stephen Fry & other twitteratti) follow about the same number who follow them, in my case it’s 291 to 326, which presumably means that a lot of the people who started by following me, & with whom I didn’t reciprocate, have dropped away – shame on you for such good sense.

Then there’s the people who just want to sell me something, anything, everything; over and over and over again. To them I apply the wonderful phrase that I learnt from Karen Skidmore “Vuvuzela Marketing”

Finally it struck me earlier today what I really don’t like about Twitter, I was catching up on some blogs and I came across Hugh MacLeod’s “gaping void” cartoon from July 21st. Incidentally if you don’t follow Hugh then you really ought to, I don’t know if he tweets, but his cartoons are just brilliant. His website is here www.gapingvoidgallery.com.

What Twitter represents far too much to me is in this cartoon.

Advertisements

One Response

  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Kevin Rose and Alun Rees, Old Mac Donald. Old Mac Donald said: Twitter – I'm torn. | Alun Rees: The title says it all really, I have two contrasting views on Twitter. First up i… http://bit.ly/azBcKS […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: